← Lineage & Critique

A Theory of Justice · 1971

John Rawls

ANCESTORADOPTEDDIVERGED

The closest ancestor in the register: the constitutional spine and the veil, imported as a graduated debiasing vote; diverges on sufficientarian floors not maximin, and a ten-axis capability metric not primary goods.

Edition read. A Theory of Justice, read at the source.

What we took

The closest ancestor in the register. Priority-of-right, moral-arbitrariness and the common-asset view, which grounds rent-to-commons, the basic structure, and the veil, imported as a graduated debiasing vote that finalises how a democratic vote makes value objective-for-governance. Plus the lexical-then-weighted architecture, the just-savings posterity axis, and self-respect as the master good.

Where we diverge, and how we answer

Diverges on exactly two points: sufficientarian floors, not maximin (a value vector is threshold-commensurable but not maximand-commensurable); and a ten-axis capability metric, not primary goods, completing his own "normal range" bracket. It adds an anti-concentration ceiling for the fair value of political liberty.

The net position

The closest ancestor in the register, the constitutional spine adopted almost whole, with two conscious, bounded departures.

Every position is read at the source. See the whole register on Lineage & Critique · The System.